Going out to dinner used to be simple: sit down, order food, eat, pay, leave.
Apparently, we’ve made it much more complicated.
What happens when your friend shows up 25 minutes late? Do you wait to order—or are the appetizers already coming?
Should the person who ordered four martinis really expect everyone else to split the check evenly?
Can you send back a steak that’s overcooked? What about a dish you simply don’t like? How much are we tipping now? Is 20% still good, or has society quietly moved the goalposts while nobody was looking?
And perhaps the most important question of all:
Can everybody PLEASE put their phones away for one meal?
In this episode of The Jocular Pugilists, Phil and Tomas dive into the unwritten rules of restaurant etiquette—and discover that dining out may contain more social landmines than international diplomacy.
They debate the behaviors that make servers crazy, customers furious, friends uncomfortable and dinner tabs considerably more complicated than they need to be.
In this episode:
- The Great Check-Splitting Debate: Should everyone pay equally when one person ordered considerably more?
- The Late Friend Rule: How late is too late for a dinner reservation?
- Tipping in 2026: Is 20% still a good tip—or are expectations getting out of control?
- Sending Food Back: When you absolutely should—and when you probably shouldn't.
- Who’s Responsible When Dinner Goes Wrong: The server, the kitchen...or you?
- Phones at the Table: Harmless habit or the death of human conversation?
- Kids in Restaurants: What parents owe the other people trying to enjoy their dinner.
- The “When Harry Met Sally” Problem: How many substitutions are too many?
- Shared Appetizer Politics: Do you have to pay if you didn't eat any?
- Double-Dipping: Somehow we still need to discuss this.
- The Last Slice Rule: Can you just take it—or must you offer it around first?
- Ordering Right Before Closing: Technically legal. Morally questionable.
- Canceling Reservations at the Last Minute: Acceptable or unforgivable?
- Bringing Your Own Birthday Cake: Celebration...or restaurant faux pas?
- And the restaurant behavior that may tell you everything you need to know about a person: how they treat the staff.
Along the way, Tomas recounts an extraordinary example of hospitality at Gramercy Tavern, Phil draws on his years working in restaurants, and both men slowly confront an uncomfortable possibility:
They may be turning into the two old guys from The Muppet Show.
So grab a table, put your phone away, don't steal the restaurant's pen and for the love of God, don't eat all the cheese off the nachos.
Listen now to The Jocular Pugilists and decide for yourself:
Which restaurant rules are legitimate etiquette—and which ones are just two increasingly cranky men yelling at the dining room?
Let us know what you think.
Email Phil or Tomas at:
thejocularpugilists@gmail.com
And check out our website at: thejocularpugilists.com